Additional dotfiles

.vaults/Rater Notes/Rating Overview/Needs Met.md

@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
+Based on both the query and the result.
+## Fully Meets
+
+Few queries can have fully meets results.
+
+Only applies when all of the following are true:
+- The query interpretation and user intent is ==specific, clear, and unambiguous==.
+- There is a ==specific website, webpage, or know-simple fact== or other specific result that all or almost all users in the rating locale and user location are looking for.
+- All or almost all users in the rating locale and user location would be completely satisfied by the result.
+
+## Highly Meets
+
+Results are highly satisfying and a good "fit" for reasonable interpretations and intents.
+
+- ==Entertaining or enjoyable== for queries with a reasonable entertainment intent.
+- Representative of the opinions, perspectives and experience of real people for queries with no single right answer.
+- For informational queries, very helpful results that, for example:
+	- Are easy to understand the content, e.g., helpful images or videos, an easy to understand summary.
+	- Provide in-depth or insightful content, e.g., a deep dive explanation, an expert analysis.
+- For queries that benefit from recently created content, fresh results that provide ==up-to-date content== on "what everyone is talking about right now" e.g., breaking news on a topic or the latest viral video or a hot new fashion trend.
+
+- ==Accuracy is required== for Highly Meets informational results.
+- Information pages on ==YMYL topics must be accurate and trustworthy==.
+- Medical/Scientific information pages must represent ==well-established consensus== unless the user is clearly seeking an alternative viewpoint.
+
+## Moderately Meets
+
+Still "fits" the query, but less satisfying than HM results.
+
+Assigned to helpful results for any reasonable interpretation or user intent of the query, including reasonable minor interpretations and intents.
+
+- May be ==less representative of the opinions, perspectives and experience== of real people for queries with no single right answer.
+- For informational queries, MM results might have content that is ==slightly harder to understand== than HM results.
+- MM results may be ==slightly out of date== for queries that benefit from recently created content.
+
+MM is an acceptable rating if you see aspects that are HM but other aspects seem SM.
+
+## Slightly Meets
+
+Results that are less helpful for a reasonable query interpretation or user intent.
+
+==Slightly Meets can also be an appropriate rating for a result which is related to the user’s information need without fully addressing it, as long as it provides some value to the user. However, if the user is looking for a specific piece of information, a result which does not provide that information, or a result which misses a key aspect of the query, cannot be rated Slightly Meets and should be rated Fails to Meet.==
+
+## Fails to Meet
+
+Assigned to results that fail to meet the needs of all or almost all users.
+
+Should be rated FM if it is clear the user is not looking for such content:
+- Harmful to Self or Other Individuals
+- Harmful to Specified Groups
+- Harmfully Misleading Information
+- Untrustworthy
+- Spammy
+- Porn

.vaults/Rater Notes/Rating Overview/Page Quality.md

@@ -0,0 +1,92 @@
+PQ is independent of NM
+
+## Steps
+1. Assess the true purpose of the page.
+2. Assess the potential of the page to cause harm.
+3. Otherwise, the PQ rating is based on how well the page achieves its purpose.
+## Considerations
+- Purpose of page
+- Potential to cause harm
+- The type of website
+- Information provided by the website and content creator
+- Quality of the MC
+- Page Title
+- The role of Ads and SC on the page
+- Reputation of the website and content creator
+- Trustworthiness of the page: E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trust)
+
+## Highest Quality
+
+Pages that serve a ==beneficial purpose== and ==achieve that purpose very well==. 
+
+- Beneficial purpose
+- Not expected to cause harm
+- Title that summarizes the page
+- Ads and SC do not block or significantly interfere with the MC
+- Adequate information about the website and content creator
+- MC created with a very high level of effort, originality, talent, or skill
+- Very positive reputation of the website
+- Very positive reputation of the content creator
+
+The distinction between High and Highest is based on:
+- The Quality of the MC
+- The reputation of the Website and Content Creator
+- EEAT
+
+## High Quality
+
+Pages that serve a ==beneficial purpose== and ==achieve that purpose well==.
+
+- Beneficial purpose
+- Not expected to cause harm
+- Title summarizes the page
+- Ads and SC do not block or significantly interfere with the MC
+- Adequate information about the website and content creator
+- MC created with a high level of effort, originality, talent, or skill
+- Positive reputation of the website
+- Positive reputation of the content creator
+
+## Medium Quality
+
+Pages that have a ==beneficial purpose== and ==achieve their purpose==. There is ==nothing wrong== with these pages.
+
+- Beneficial or non-harmful purpose
+- Not expected to cause harm
+- Title that summarizes the page
+- Ads and SC do not block or significantly interfere with the MC
+- Adequate information about the website and content creator
+- MC created with adequate effort, originality, talent, or skill
+- Not especially positive nor especially negative reputation
+
+## Low Quality
+
+Pages that do not achieve their purpose well because they are ==lacking in an important dimension== or have a ==problematic aspect==.
+
+- Beneficial or non-harmful purpose
+- No potential or Mild potential for harm
+- Content creator lacks adequate experience
+- Website or Content creator is not an authoritative or trustworthy source for the topic
+- Low Effort, Originality, or Added Value for Website Visitors
+- Distracting Ads/SC
+- Mildly Negative Reputation
+- Unsatisfying Amount of Information
+
+## Lowest Quality
+
+Pages are ==untrustworthy, deceptive, harmful to people or society==, or have other highly undesirable characteristics.
+
+- Harmful or Deceives
+	- Deceptive Purpose
+	- Deceptive Information
+	- Deceptive Design
+- Harmfully misleading information
+- Benefits the owner with very little or no attempt to benefit website visitors
+- Hacked, Defaced, or Spammed
+- Gibberish or makes no sense
+- Little Effort, little to no originality, adds no value
+- Title is misleading, shocking, or exaggerated
+- MC is obstructed or obscured
+- A complete lack of information about who is responsible for the website and its content for pages requiring trust
+- Negative reputation
+- Untrustworthy
+